FEI proposal to remove dressage collective marks puts harmony in focus
British Equestrian supports assessing harmony through every movement, while other stakeholders want to retain or strengthen the overall assessment at the end of a test.
By Everything Horse Editorial Team | 18 November 2026
A proposal to remove collective marks from international dressage is heading towards the FEI’s December decision-making process, putting the way judges recognise harmony under renewed scrutiny.
The central question is where that assessment belongs: in a separate overall mark after the performance, or within the scores awarded throughout the test. The proposal has not yet been approved.
What is being proposed?
The FEI Dressage Technical Committee recommends removing collective marks and assessing harmony and the training scale within individual technical movements.
The report states that British Equestrian supports this approach at international level, arguing that it could simplify the scoring explanation and reduce the potential for unconscious bias. Its position distinguishes international competition from lower-level national sport, where collectives can support riders’ education and development.
Other stakeholders favour a different direction. The European Equestrian Federation and German federation support an additional collective assessment rather than its removal. The disagreement concerns the best mechanism for rewarding correct work, rather than whether harmony matters.
How an overall mark differs from a movement score
In the FEI’s published 2025 dressage rules, individual movements and specified transitions are scored from zero to ten. Article 423 also provides for an overall collective mark after the performance, with coefficients determining the weighting of particular marks.
That structure separates two perspectives. A movement score records the quality of a specific piece of work. A collective mark allows an overall assessment after the judge has seen the complete performance.
The proposed change would shift emphasis towards the first approach. Removing a separate box would not, by itself, remove the need to assess the quality of the partnership. Its effectiveness would depend on how that requirement is expressed and applied through the movement scores.
The 2025 rulebook provides historical context for the marking structure, rather than confirmation of the final 2027 wording.
Part of a wider review of the sport
The discussion follows a substantial programme of work presented at the FEI Sports Forum in March. The FEI’s forum report, reproduced by Eurodressage, described 30 initial recommendations covering judging, horse wellbeing, tack, stewarding, communication and education.
British rider Gareth Hughes is among the members of the Dressage Strategic Action Plan Working Group. The forum also examined judge monitoring, consistency and the development of updated judging guidance.
That context matters because changing the score sheet is only one part of reform. Clear criteria, judge education and consistent application are needed for riders to understand how the quality of training is being rewarded.
Test revisions and judging rules are separate developments
The FEI has also issued a summary of dressage test revisions for 2027, hosted by the Brazilian equestrian federation. It includes changes across young-horse and senior tests, including a stretch circle within the Grand Prix programme.
Those test revisions should not be treated as evidence that the separate proposal on collective marks has passed. Riders need the final approved rules and the correct edition of their test sheet.
For British competitors, international proposals also do not automatically establish changes to every national or unaffiliated class. The applicable governing body’s rules and the competition schedule remain the reference points.



